The Prez, a Bug and Some Nuts
Tuesday, June 23rd, 2009By Beth Quinn
If ever there was a group of good-intentioned people who have lost their sense of proportion, it has to be PETA – the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals.
This is not news. I think most of us have had doubts about the group since they began their “Jesus was a vegetarian” campaign a few Easters ago. If that didn’t do it, a lot more fans bailed when PETA started bad-mouthing the nutritional value of cow’s milk because, they said, it’s cruel to milk a cow. (Believe me – cows really WANT to be milked every 12 hours. I know from experience that they complain bitterly if the farmer is late to the barn.)
Even so, we were once again reminded of PETA’s tenuous hold on reality this past week when the group took President Obama to task for killing a fly.
If you happened to have missed it, a fly intruded on a televised interview with Obama by CNBC correspondent Jim Harwood. When the buzzing, dive-bombing fly failed to follow a direct order from the president (“Get out of here,” he told it), the president caught the bug in his hand and smacked it dead.
I was thoroughly impressed. He seems to have some kind of laser bug beam, able to zero in on a flying target and take it out. He was proud of himself, too. “That was pretty impressive, wasn’t it? I got the sucker,” he said to Harwood. And because our president is no litterbug with dead bugs, he later cleaned up the carcass with a napkin.
Alas, PETA was not at all impressed with the president’s skills. After the bug slaying, the group issued a statement urging Obama to be more compassionate to all animals. They also sent a Katcha Bug Humane Bug Catcher to the White House, a device that allows users to trap house flies and release them outside. I suppose the Secret Service could be enlisted to perform this chore.
I first became aware that PETA took a rather extreme view of bug-killing at least 15 years ago when I wrote a column called “Scout Catches a Bug.” Scout, as you may recall, was my little brown dog, and she entertained herself by chasing every bug that entered our house. This led to many ripped screens and much broken crockery, but that was a small price to pay for a bug-free house.
At any rate, in that column I described one particular fly-catching moment, during which Scout leapt onto my dresser in pursuit of a bug and busted just about everything up there, including a bottle of make-up. In the manner of good writers, I chose to be specific – it wasn’t just “a bottle of make-up” that Scout broke and smeared all over the place, but a bottle of “L’Oreal Shimmering Bronze make-up.”
Well, how was I to know L’Oreal did animal testing. If I thought about it at all, I suppose I pictured little lab rats checking how they looked in the mirror wearing the company’s latest lipstick color.
I was to learn otherwise. PETA began sending me pictures of little rats being waterboarded by cosmetics experts. The group accused me of aiding and abetting the torture of animals. They so intimidated me that, years later, when I included that column in a book of dog stories, I edited out the name of the make-up company.
In truth, I am horrified at the notion of animal cruelty. As a child, I had to leave the theater during “101 Dalmatians,” crying at the thought of what Cruella Deville had planned for those puppies. Now that we have the movie on DVD for our grandchildren, I’m only marginally less inclined to cover my eyes and ears at the scary parts.
Yet, like most people, I’m probably a little confused about where I draw the line. I wear leather and eat meat. If a fly is hurling itself at a screen in an effort to get out of the house, I’ll raise the window and try to assist. However, if my investment in the fly’s welfare goes beyond a minute or so, I lose interest and urge one of my dogs to have at it.
(Neither is as successful as Scout was. Huckleberry corkscrews herself straight up for a mid-air snatch at the bug, but she often misses. Tom is more of an ox, hurling his full weight in the bug’s direction but arriving at his destination long after the bug itself has moved on.)
In any case, despite my love of animals, I’m no purist and would never be a member in good standing with PETA. I’ll admit, though, that I’m grateful for their efforts, however weird they may sometimes be. We need such people. Extremists in any good cause help us to find a decent middle ground.
None of this, however, mitigates my admiration for the Fly Swatter-in-Chief’s mid-air zap. Of him, I have only this to say – that guy is soooooo fly!
Beth can be reached at beth@zestoforange.com.